Is Mariah Carey really in the same league as Diana Ross, Elvis and The Beatles?!


Question: Mariah Carey just tied Elvis and Diana Ross with 18 #1 hits. She is only 2 shy of the Beatles at 20. In all likelihood, she will surpass the Beatles before she retires.

Does anybody else think that Mariah Carey is NOT EVEN CLOSE to being the greatest artist of all time?


Answers: Mariah Carey just tied Elvis and Diana Ross with 18 #1 hits. She is only 2 shy of the Beatles at 20. In all likelihood, she will surpass the Beatles before she retires.

Does anybody else think that Mariah Carey is NOT EVEN CLOSE to being the greatest artist of all time?

Hell no !!!!!

I agree......but there's just more people in the world today, and she's making new music and those others aren't anymore.....somebody was bound to surpass them...I'm just sorry it's her.....

I am not a huge Mimi fan but if she came out with 18 #1 singles then why question it? Who do you think is the greatest artist of all time? How many #1 singles did they come out with? Hummm...not nearly enough as Mimi. Not everyone out there has 18 NUMBER 1 SINGLES and still going. And yes she will surpass The Beatles and it's not her fault no one up until now has done so. Give credit to where credit is due!

I saw her perform her most recent "hit" on tv the other day and it was exceptionally bland. At first I thought there was something wrong with the tv but then realized it was just a crap song. Her people know how to market her. I guess that has a lot to do with it. It certainly is telling of our times when Mariah is the top seller. There are so many great singers and groups out there who are deserving. It's a shame really that a silly diva takes the prize.

I agree. She's not even in the same league as them. I really don't see why people like her. Her songs are just generic that you can hear from 50 other singers of today. So, she may pass the Beatles with #1 singles but the Beatles will always be better than her.

i agree! she hasnt been in the music biz for very long. not 40+ years like the beatles or diana ross! her music isnt all that good, thats my opinion. and she cant sing that well, again my opinion. i mean how can you compare a song like "golden slumbers" or "let it be" or "suspicious minds" with some "song" called "touch my body"!?!? she's gonna have to come up with some REALLY GOOD chart-toppers if she wants to win all the audiances in America like the beatles and elvis.

I don't think she is even close to the Beatles

i think because she's an active artist in "today's music," people don't think she is worthy of being historic in the music business. i mean this is the same woman who created vision of love, hero, one sweet day, we belong together. 'touch my body' isnt even supposed to be a serious song

....but trust me her next song is soooooo deep! i SWEAR to you! its called 'bye bye.' i wish it was out now so people would stop judging her over one simple song!!!! agh! but i think she is worthy of being the greatest artist of all time.

ummm ya i think she is the greatest and she has 18 wonderful number 1's to prove it...



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories