Why do most of the people dislike One Piece ?!


Question: Why do most of the people dislike One Piece !?
Its a great anime, and I happen to like it!. Why do some people think that Bleach and Naruto think its better than One Piece!?

I know for a fact that the base of fans are all equal for all three of these great anime shows!. I've seen the yaoi versions of all these anime, fanfics are in the same amount of these shows, and so on!. And, the AMVs made for all three of the shows have been made on youtube!. I just don't see why most of everyone on Yahoo!Answers has to hate One Piece!.

If you hate it, give me a good reason that you do!.

If you love the show, just state it so!.Www@Enter-QA@Com


Answers:
Ah, okay!.!.!.!. now I think I have a different thought about this!. Because I can see there's two group of people didn't like One Piece!.
1!. Thoughts from Seinen fan
2!. Thoughts from Shonen fan

Yes, there is Seinen fan here!. I can clearly see that!. One thing you should know, never compared a Seinen series with Shonen series!. If you prefer a series that don't have a loud mouth character and has a lot more intellectual and makes your brain works more, then One Piece isn't your forte!. Although if you pay attention, OP do makes your brains work (only if you want to)!.

Example : The Straw Hats travel to Alabasta, the desert island!. They find the country in the middle of a revolution!. Sir Crocodile, the country's hero, secretly used his criminal organization, Baroque Works, to undermine the citizens trust in the King in order to seize the throne and the countries hidden secret for himself!.

Key word here is desert island and Baroque Works!. Can you so called 'thinking people' deduced the hidden meaning behind it!? No!? Okay then!. Short form of Baroque Work is B!.W!. If you take a look on the maps, B!.W is referred as the desert!. Fun isn't it!? Don't let me go through the scientific explanation about each of the character's ability okay!. Do the thinking yourself (only if you want to)

To Shonen fan, here's the reason why the didn't like OP (since that long answer is such a drag, I decided to keep this one simple XD)
1!. They saw 4Kids dubbed!.
2!. They hate One Piece art because they're used to the art after the year 2000
3!. Story is so long and feels like a dragged on
4!. They think One Piece plot and storyline is stupid and kiddish
5!. The main character is annoying
6!. They didn't like Pirates!. They're more into Ninja and Samurai! (or Vampire!.!.!.)
7!. No romance or fan speculate pairing couple

Now, to answer them
1!. Never watched the 4Kids dubbed!. They're made for kids (pun intended)!. What do you expect from that!? Toy water guns instead of actual shot gun!? Hell yeah!

2!. Art!? One Piece started on 1997 and their art is original and distinct!. You can't compare then to other shonen series that came out after 2000!. By the way, you can clearly see the art has improved since then!. Without losing their originality!. I wanted to rants more about this, but I won't!. This is a vague subject to be arguing about!.

3!. Story has been dragging on!? Shesshh!.!.!. pay attention when you read/watch people!. Refer to this Q
http://answers!.yahoo!.com/question/index;!.!.!.
- The series has been building up their arc from the start!. Pay attention next time and don't just expect the storyline to be told later by the mangaka!. The series that has well organized and planned out storyline is NOT a dragging series!.

4!. Storyline is stupid and kiddish!? Youtube video will explains better!
http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=7WVqzWAHH!.!.!.
http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=QWxySfkhe!.!.!.
http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=_JiQZPnfb!.!.!.
- They're not your typical fight the villain to protect their beloved village/city!. They covered a lot of things, from the revenge for a friends, to the rebellion arcs, to retrieved their friends!.
- Don't let me start with Norland and Calgara friendship though!.

5!. Main character is annoying!? You know you're reading Shonen right!? Almost all of Shonen main character is annoying because they're expressive and loud!.
- I recommend them to read Seinen series if they want much more calm and quiet main character!. (only if you are 18 and above)

6!. Didn't like pirates!. This one can't be help!. It's in their blood!. People will always fascinating on others culture!. Ninja and Samurai looks cool to them because they're not Japanese!. Same goes to Japanese, they thinks OP is cool because pirates isn't part of their culture!.
- Noticed that some of the mangaka will usually stereotypes the foreigners (non Jap) for being obsessed with Ninja and Samurai!?

7!. Romance!. Shonen actually attracts more fan girls than fan boys!. Nobuhiro Watsuki (Rurouni Kenshin mangaka) admit this because he received more fan girl letters than fan boys!.
- This is why you can see lots of fans pairing this girl with that guy, or this guy with that guy (Yaoi) or this girl with that girl (Yuri) or that kids with his mom (!?!! Incest!)!.
- Conclusion, girls like pairing up a Shonen character!.!.!. OP didn't have that much of pairing choice!. Naruto and Bleach has this fan speculates relationship because the mangaka intentionally hints that!. While OP don't, they just don't used that cheesy idea!.
- Although the current chapter has a bit of romance between Luffy and Boa Hancock (thanks to those that forgot to put spoiler alert before the sentences >__<)!. We might see more romance in the future!? I guess not!. Oda always states that his view of 'romance' is different as it's not always about love and relationship!. It's about adventure (hence the name of the first chapter - Romance Dawn)Www@Enter-QA@Com

I don't like it for a few reasons!.!.!.

1) When I first started reading Shonen Jump in America, I bought it exclusively to read Naruto!. I always felt One Piece took pages away that naruto could have had, so there's the first (this was about, idk 2 years ago)
2) It is horribly drawn!. I think I've seen better drawn characters in the Sunday comics!.
3) It's story, from what I know, is not entertaining!.
4)The main character is very very annoying!.
5) the 4Kids dub!.

I don't know if any of these points are that valid, but I still don't like it :DWww@Enter-QA@Com

one piece, naruto and bleach are all overated

hmmm could be because it is censored!? at least!.!.!. cartoon network censored a lot of stuff from it!. also i don't think pirates looking for a treasure make up a good storyline!. i don't like bleach or naruto either!. long series are often full of "fill-up" episodes, so that's another reason!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

I love One Piece! It is different, the characters are totally off the wall and it's just plain fun to watch! I know some do not like the dubbed version and that could turn them off to the Anime!. I myself like dubbed because iA prefer to just sit and watch an Anime and not have my eyes dart all over the screen!. But, I did not like the voice actor changes when it got a new distributor!. I suppose in time I will learn to not lit bother me!. But over all, I really like One Piece and am sorry there are so many who do not!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

As much as I love Naruto and Bleach!. It's true!. These 3 are overrated!.!.!.
I mean I love Katekyo as well!. :) (sucks that FUNimation told Phantom-Subs to stop subbing Katekyo!. :( )

But I guess I just didnt want to watch One Piece cause there are over 300 eps!. D: I watched all of Naruto cause I was already watching it as well as Bleach!.

But yeah!.!.!. I have nothing against One Peice but I dont intend to watch it either!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

I love one Piece!

Theyr'e definitely great, the plot is ok and it was so cool!.

I love both manga/anime and very proud of it!

I collect the Portrait of Pirates figure:

I got Luffy 3 poses

Shanks

Nami

Chopper

Zoro

Sanji

http://www!.hlj!.com/product/MEG71141

and as far as I know!.!. AdDam collects the Manga Volume!.

I like One Piece soooooooo much!Www@Enter-QA@Com

It's probably because of the artwork (some ppl can be shallow >!.>)



Edit: Sorry, i didn't mean to offend you by the "Artwork" opinion, i personally think that the artwork is really good!. But most ppl i know would drop it just by looking at the manga cover (a lot of my friends did that >!.<)






-have a nice day =DWww@Enter-QA@Com

I don't like the art in One Piece, that's the main reason I don't like it!.

I also don't like Naruto so much and Bleach is decent enough!.

That's just my opinion though!. Even though I don't like it, I won't say it's a bad anime or anything like that!. :)Www@Enter-QA@Com

lol Shockwave!. that's a lot coming from a person who's avatar is Pit!. heh heh!. just kidding! ^^ but seriously Pit does suck!.!.!.!.

as for ur question, i actually do kinda like it!. the animation is pretty good but i watched it when i was younger and i thought the magic fruit thing was real and when i realized it wasnt i was really mad at the show!.!.!. true story!.!.!. although i think i might get into it again since im over the whole "lying fruit show" phase!.!.!.!. >__> Www@Enter-QA@Com

*raises hand* I like- no LOVE One Piece!. ^^

You know it's the art!. Some people just base the anime on the first episode, so when they see how bad the art is, they judge the anime by that!. =\






ONE PIECE, DAISUKE!. ^_____^Www@Enter-QA@Com

I like the story, but i dislike the character design!. :S
I prefer the design of Katekyo Hitman REBORN!, Naruto, Dragonball or Bleach!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

i think ppl aren't in to OP as much as they could be is be cuz 4kids screwed the show when it first came to the U!.S!.
it's popularity might increase now the funimtion is dubbing it!. Www@Enter-QA@Com

I refuse to even try to watch One Piece because I know from experience that more than about sixty seconds exposure to that pathetic pseudo-cartoon starts to give me a headache!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

i love One Piece!
i think it's very interesting because of the storyline and unique artwork!.
but not all people appreciate the artwork!.
they stick to the usual ones!.:PWww@Enter-QA@Com

Luffy's voice changed!!!
and his brother Ace isn't seen as much as i would like to see him so that made me mad!.!.!.plus ninja's rule^^
and Bleach is cool!.!.!.i like Kubo's drawing style!Www@Enter-QA@Com

!.!.!.I personally just don't like the way it's drawn!. I don't like the style of it!. But that's just my opinion :)Www@Enter-QA@Com

I love it!. But it's long and maybe some people think the animation is kiddish!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

Because its one piece!

There should be like at least 4, then i would watchWww@Enter-QA@Com

Probably since 4kids killed it!. That's why!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

I love One Piece even though i prefer shojo

Actually the time that it was shown , i had already made up my mind to watch it, but since i prefer watching animes that are already done, i just decided not to watch it now, but just buy it after its done!.
But thanks to somebody who insisted that i ought to buy it even if its not yet done!.!. seeing as its already in season 10

Anyway, sorry about the ramblings!.!.on with the question!.!.!.

When watching something, the first thing that most people see of course,is the ART!. For an average person,he/she prefers to watch something that is 'good looking', aint it!? Something that will make their eyes go 'wow' because it is 'nice'!.

did you get to see the part where nami is slumped on the ground, crying, her arms bloody because she stabbed it just to remove arlong's tattoo!.!.!?
that one really made me cry!.!. TT_TT *sniff*
http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=fUg8XLiup!.!.!.

also when luffy is climbing the mountain to get to the dr kureha just to save nami!?
nami is at his back, he is biting sanji's shirt!.!.!.his hands are already bloody & you can clearly see that his body is frostbitten already!.!.!.but he did his best!.!.just to save nami!.!.!.
he said to kureha to save them because
"They're my nakama!"
*teary eyed*

there are lots of good OP moments

looking at how it was done!.!.!.how touching those scenes are!.!.!.
how can that be a bad art!?!

looking at these pics!.!.!.
http://upload!.wikimedia!.org/wikipedia/en!.!.!.
http://www!.mangafox!.com/page/manga/read/!.!.!.

can you actually say that this art is bad!?

though i gotta admit, its a bit different compare to the usual 'anime art standard', but then this just mean that someone has decided to break the usual standard & come up with another one

*inner shojo speaking*
it made me cry, that not even good shojos had made me!.!.
Fushigi Yuugi is 1 of my fave & the OVA made me cry (yeah!.!.!.not the series)
& OP is the only one who had me cry aside from FY!.!.

my advice is:
-give it a try!.!.!.if you give OP a chance!. it wouldn't be ongoing for years if it was bad,right!?

Oh, One more thing about why c&a people doesn't like it, aside from the number 1 reason of ART is that its LONG

it already span in its 10th season, for people who might wanna start watching it, this can be a drawback!. It will take lots of their time starting from scratch!.

But for people who appreciate GOOD ANIME, this is not a reason to stop them, actually this is suppose to be a good reason to start watching!. it just means that the longer it takes, the better the story develops!.

but then it deserves to be justified,ain't it!?Www@Enter-QA@Com

Your guess is as good as mine!. I remeber when I first saw OnePiece when it was FoxBox or 4Kids (whatever name they were going by at the time)!. The intro had me hooked with the pictures and music and the main character Luffy being your not so average pirate!. He's the good kind of pirate who has managed to befriend non-pirate types into his crew!. Bleach, Naruto and OnePiece are basically on the same page seeing how they are all Shonen!. The main characters are relunctant heros at times and they have a tendency of putting others before themselves when time came to it!. No one anime is better than the other!. But of course there are SOME exceptions!. Not many, but some!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

I LOVE ONE PIECE!~~~
it's already my favourite, I love it more than any anime, it's the perfect for me, the humour is great, the characters are awesome, the story is unique and interesting(there're few animes on pirates), even the fillers are good, one of the filler arcs is my favourite believe it or not, the villains change and there's a lot from them not only 1 or 2 groups like other animes!.!.!.!. it doesn't have typical anime girls, it has more than one main character which makes you have more than a favourite and everyone is different from the other and it's not concentrated on only one topic and one place! it changes every time, so if you get bored from this arc the next arc will be promising!.!.!. it has more than one arc, it's a true adventurous anime and what might annoy people I love the art!!! the artwork is just the best! and it goes well with the characters and the story, but I have to say the comedy is the best!
nothing is bad about One Piece, everything is perfect, lol I mentioned the reasons why it's so good, ummmmm I think people hates it for these reasons:
1!. they don't like the art, they say it's childish but they dunno that it's what makes one piece so unique and fun!!
2!. most of them have seen the sh!tty dub!! 4kids killed it very badly but they say that's One Piece, I mean just go and see the original One Piece and you'll know how great One Piece is!.!.!.

what makes One Piece that awesome is Luffy! omg I can't tell you how much i love him, he makes One Piece fun to watch!!Www@Enter-QA@Com

I have no clue why people don't like One Piece!!! Probably because they never give it a chance!.

I keep reading about how they Prefer Bleach and Naruto, and how it's soo much better!.

Well, I HAVE SEEN BOTH BLEACH AND NARUTO like over 100 episodes of each!. And At first IT THOUGHT NARUTO was REALLY COOL!. Then, It got BORING IN MY OPINION so I STOPPED WATCHING IT FOREVER!.

Then, Bleach I still Like, but I just stopped watching it for some reason, I forgot though, but I haven't watched it for months and and don't feel like watching it!. But I still think it's awesome

THEN ONE PIECE!!! IT'S MY FAVORITE ANIME AND MANGA EVER, I DON'T CARE WHAT PEOPLE SAY ABOUT IT, IT'S ONE OF THE BEST ANIME EVER CREATED AND I LOVE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Www@Enter-QA@Com

I happen to like One Piece a lot more than Naruto and Bleach combined!. I used to like Bleach and Naruto more, but then a friend of mine got me hooked on the subbed version and I suddenly saw how bad the others were!. That and I started watching Yu Yu Hakusho again and realized how similar Bleach is to it!.

Most people don't like One Piece because of what 4Kids did to it!. Then there's the "artwork" stick that I don't buy!. After that it's the originality!.

Examples: Buggy the Clown separating his body parts apart, Robin growing limbs off any surface, Chopper the blue nose doctor Reindeer (not as original as the first two, but I'm trying to make a point!.)

But I like One Piece more, and for AMV's of it I turn to giasecando!. His Youtube profile is below here!.

http://www!.youtube!.com/user/giasecando

Www@Enter-QA@Com

WOW!
There are a lot of hackin answers!.!.!.no ones gonna to read mine!.!.!.!.!. *sob*

Well anyways!.!.!.i really really do not like one piece!. At all!. (Sorryyy!!)
Basically, it's just not my kinda story!.!.!.it really doesn't hold my interest too well!.
It's a bit obnoxious and immature!.!.!.and that's coming from ME!
(I usually don't mind obnoxious and immature! ^^)

And i really do appreciate how the art is different and unique to the normal anime style (seriously! everything looks the same!) !.!.!.but i just don't like to watch that kind style!. Lol
I'm snobby that way i guess!.!.!.i like pretty characters!. And i think most people do too!.!.!. =/

I am not hater of popular anime!.!.!.I LOOOOOVE Naruto and Bleach!.!.!.no matter what ANYONE says!.!.!.i think they are really great, interesting,revolutionary shows that have made huge impact on anime today!.

One piece!.!.!.not so much!.!.!.it's just not one that ever comes up!.!.!.it hasn't earned the right!.!.!. and!.!.!.*gulp*!.!.!.i'm glad!.
The less i see of one piece the better!.
(again, sorryyy!) :(
<3Www@Enter-QA@Com

This is AdDam's answer

Uh huh!.!.!.!. just so you know, only people in C&A dislikes One Piece!. If you go to youtube, you'll see a lot of OP fan from all around the world!. Anyway, from my observation here in C&A, they hated One Piece because

1!. They watched 4Kids dubbed!.?
- Refer to this guy Q, he listed top 10 worst things 4Kids made to One Piece!.?
http://answers!.yahoo!.com/question/index!?!.!.!.
- The company basically made OP the most misunderstood anime ever in the world (or maybe just in C&A)
- I mean, come on!? Changing the guns into a toy water guns!? Take out all the blood!? Sanji sucking a lollipop!? More importantly, they take out the original scene in the manga (Laboon arc)!. To the people that read OP, they'll know this arc is really important!. There would be a plot hole without that arc!. Thank goodness 4Kids canceled the dub!.

2!. They hate?One Piece art!.
- Let me ask those people that criticize OP art!. Please draw something that has originality, and has distinct style that set your drawing apart from the rest!. Can you people do it!? Okay, after you find your originality, please make a well organized storyline and put some hidden character in some of the panel, hidden word on some of the panel, and hidden future plot while you're closer and closer to the dead line like OP mangaka did!. Can you people do that!?
- DO NOT judge a series by its art!. Judge the series by their storyline!. This is like you're judging a person with their looks and appearance, not their personality and say "Personality is more important"!. That's hypocrite!. Show some respect to the artist please!. Because I noticed some of you here wanted to be a mangaka or an artist!. But with that kinda attitude - "This art looks ugly" or "I don't like the art" - You won't get anywhere because you don't have a sense of respect of others artwork!.Every artist has their own style!. Do you have your own style or you just copied someone else's style!?
- Oh yeah, if you don't like?OP art, please do not watch and read this following series?Dragon Ball,?Rave Master,?Shaman King,?Fairy Tail, Sailormoon, Detective Conan and a lot other series I can't mention here because those series also has unorthodox style that you didn't like!. Ah, put?Astro Boy?on the list too because?Osamu Tezuka?also has unorthodox style when drawing his character!.?
- I called those people - Orginal!. They have their own style that makes people goes "Hey I know this artist!"!. Even?Hiro Mashima?(mangaka of Rave Master & Fairy Tail) gets a lot of pressure because people kept saying he copied?Eiichiro Oda?(mangaka of OP) art style!.

3!.? Story is so long and dragged on!.!.!.?
- Ah come on!.!.!. you guys are too lazy to noticed that each arc has been planned all along by the mangaka!. Look at this Q?
http://answers!.yahoo!.com/question/index;!.!.!.
- This is one of few shonen series that doesn't make up a storyline for the sake of making more money!. They're all has been setting up by the mangaka!. You're just need to pay attention to each arc to get the hidden future plot!. Wait, people didn't like that!. They prefer a series that doesn't stressed themselves to think!. They're just accepting the plot of their favorite series eventhough they already saw it coming!.
- If we're talking about Shonen series, I prefer a series that start off slowly and build of the momentum and getting better and better after that!. NOT a series that start off good, and then, they going up and down!.!.!. and then becomes boring, and then they're good again!.!.!. and then they're going down again!. Consistency is the key!. One Piece has been consistent through all this 11 years of publishing!. Why do you think this series sold +140 million copies each volume in the first week while other series like Naruto barely get to 100 million copies after a month they've been released!?
4!. One Piece plot and storyline is stupid! There's no serious moment, always a goofing off and annoying moment!.
- Watch this youtube trailer and see for yourself how 'stupid' One Piece is
http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=7WVqzWAHH!.!.!.
- Do you think that one is stupid!? They avenged their friend that has becomes a slave to the person that killed her mother! Of course, this wasn't the full story because that will take a lot of space to explain to you how serious this storyline really is!.?
http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=QWxySfkhe!.!.!.
- Do you think this one is stupid too!? A Princess trying to stop a war between the Royal Army and Rebellion Army only by herself!? Oh, did I mention there's a man behind the curtain that has his own agenda on taking over the country after the two army collapse!. Okay, maybe this arc is too serious for kids that only into action and non sense fighting!.!.!.!.
http://www!.youtube!.com/watch!?v=_JiQZPnfb!.!.!.
- If you think this one iWww@Enter-QA@Com

I just dont like pirates!.

Never have!.

Never will!.

I dont even like pirates of the caribbean (or however you spell it)


SO, to me, pirates are just straight up GAYWww@Enter-QA@Com



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories