Psychology and astrology coincidences?!


Question: Do you find this concepts similar?

Id, ego and supergo with Sun, moon and ascendant


Answers: Do you find this concepts similar?

Id, ego and supergo with Sun, moon and ascendant

They do go hand in hand indeed,
Like mhiaa mentioned..............Carl Jung !!
Serious astrologers also study psychology. I wanted to be a psychologist but could not ( won't explain why..family stuff) so I resorted to reading books instead but was left unsatisfied. All those black/white, compartment- like.kind of stereotyping people. Good/bad etc.
Was a bit like reading books about diseases/heath : you just start to become convinced that you are bound to to get this and that.
Have a look at Liz Greene (who was first a certified psychologist but took an interest in astrology and found a shortcut there to answer people's problems). She gave an example in one of her book about one of her client who went to see a psychologist because she felt she "was going nuts" and the psy agreed.....she was having a bad time at the time with a certain transit..forgot which though and was much reassured and felt much more understood.
But I would ( everybody has their own opinion)
Take the Sun as the Ego
Mars /venus as the Id
Superego : Saturn.

Yes, I guess there is only so many theories one can have. Many theorists have material which is similar. Look at some spiritual andd religious theories, different religions, same concept.

now that i think about it...yes, they basicly are the same thing, just differnet words

Psychology and astrology go hand in hand. I studied both. The psychology of elements fire, air, earth , water was an awesome book.
So , if you know psychology, the readings are much easier on a mental level. At least, for me, anyways.

Medical astrology, also is good and has some psychological influence for mental sickness.

Dr. Carl Jung. Ring a bell? Research him and his association with astrology. Heck, even the last book on the I Ching I bought (what 20 years go?) had an introduction by him.



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories