A HARD riddle . C A U T I O N !?!
Question: A HARD riddle !. C A U T I O N !!?
On an island , there are two tribes of people : the Lucky and the Truthful !. The Lucky tribespeople always tell lies while the people of the Truthful tribe always tell the truth !. One day , a visitor to the island met three person , A, B and C !. He was curious to know which tribe each belonged to !. He asked A but A spoke so softly that he could not hear !. B claimed that he heard what A said and told the visitor , " He says he belongs to the Lucky tribe !. " C quickly turned to B and bluntly told him , " You are a liar !. " Which tribe does A , B , and C belongs to respectively !?
can someone PLEASE help me solve it !? It's in my Maths book !. And i CANT figure it out !.Www@Enter-QA@Com
can someone PLEASE help me solve it !? It's in my Maths book !. And i CANT figure it out !.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Answers:
the key here is that B said A belongs to the LUCKY tribe!. if A was lucky then he would say truth, if A is truth he said the truth!. so no matter what, b is a liar!.
A!?
B-Liar
C!?
now, b is a liar no matter what, so C is truth!.
A!?
B-Liar
C-Truth
If C is truth then A must also be truth, because then a must have said he belonged to the truth tribe, which would have been true since B said A said he belonged to the lucky tribe!.
So!.!.!.
A-Truth
B- Liar
C-Truth
Lol im 14 and i remember doing this in front of my class in math!. Remember, no matter what, B MUST be a liar!. If A said the truth he must be in the Truth tribe, if he lies then he must have said he belonged in the Truth tribe, and B said he said he belonged to the Lucky tribe, so he must have lied!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
A!?
B-Liar
C!?
now, b is a liar no matter what, so C is truth!.
A!?
B-Liar
C-Truth
If C is truth then A must also be truth, because then a must have said he belonged to the truth tribe, which would have been true since B said A said he belonged to the lucky tribe!.
So!.!.!.
A-Truth
B- Liar
C-Truth
Lol im 14 and i remember doing this in front of my class in math!. Remember, no matter what, B MUST be a liar!. If A said the truth he must be in the Truth tribe, if he lies then he must have said he belonged in the Truth tribe, and B said he said he belonged to the Lucky tribe, so he must have lied!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
It's a trick question!. Theres no way of knowing who is in what tribe!. You cannot hear what A says so you canno tell if B is lying about what was said!. Furthermore, there is no way of knowing if C is telling the truth about what B said about A saying!. How does anyone think they can know weather A,B,or C is telling the truth!?! Theres nothing in the problem that says anything about how to tell if their lying or telling the truth so technically, there isn't enough information to solve the problem!. (I'm pretty sure that's the answer their looking for, otherwise it wouldn't be in a MATH book!)Www@Enter-QA@Com
A could not have said that he belongs to the Lucky tribe, because Lucky tribespeople are all liars, and could not tell the truth about what tribe they belong to!. Therefore, B has to be lying when he tells what A said!. If B is lying, C is telling the truth since he called B a liar!. And assuming that B did hear A, then A must have said that he belongs to the Truthful (since B's lie said that A belongs to the Lucky)!. So,
A- Truthful
B-Lucky
C-TruthfulWww@Enter-QA@Com
A- Truthful
B-Lucky
C-TruthfulWww@Enter-QA@Com
A = Truthful - because if B said that A was in the Lucky tribe, and he lied, so A is in the Truthful tribe!.
B = Lucky - because B lied about what tribe A is in!.
C = Truthful - because C told the truth saying that B is a liar!.
Hope this helps! :)Www@Enter-QA@Com
B = Lucky - because B lied about what tribe A is in!.
C = Truthful - because C told the truth saying that B is a liar!.
Hope this helps! :)Www@Enter-QA@Com
im goin to guess A is in Truthful tribe!. since the truth is hard to heard!? and B and C are in the Lucky TribeWww@Enter-QA@Com
well, i is A and c truthful b liar!. i think you might be absist!.!.!.why the heck did you lieve d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z out!? They want to be in this joke also!Www@Enter-QA@Com
A belongs to Truthful, B belongs to Lucky and C belongs to TruthfulWww@Enter-QA@Com
B is in the truthful tribe, while A and C are in the liar one!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
a and c true, b lucky
because b said he heard what a said but a was way to quiet and c called b a liar which was the truthWww@Enter-QA@Com
because b said he heard what a said but a was way to quiet and c called b a liar which was the truthWww@Enter-QA@Com
A and C true
B luckyWww@Enter-QA@Com
B luckyWww@Enter-QA@Com