People aginst Rolling stone magazine list of Immortals, greatest song and greate!
Question: does every body have something against this list I've been hearing a lot of criticism to this list. A friend of mine complained how bob Dylan was higher then Elvis (#2 on the list) and the rolling stones and also complained how chuck Barry and Hendrix was higher then James Brown and thought he should have been #3. He also complained how Nirvana and U2 were so high on this list calling them overrated and how Pink Floyd didn't make the list. He also said Eminem and Nine inch nails didn't deserve to be on that list. He also complained how like a rolling stone was ranked #1 on the best song list and how low Pink Floyd comfortably numb song was. Also complained How Pink Floyd's album dark side of the moon was ranked #43 (I think) and that there were to many Beatles albums in the top 10. Maybe Zappa said it best about rolling stone magazine about calling it stupid (Then again I really don't know I don;t have any thing against this) . So does any body else have any thing against these lists
Answers: does every body have something against this list I've been hearing a lot of criticism to this list. A friend of mine complained how bob Dylan was higher then Elvis (#2 on the list) and the rolling stones and also complained how chuck Barry and Hendrix was higher then James Brown and thought he should have been #3. He also complained how Nirvana and U2 were so high on this list calling them overrated and how Pink Floyd didn't make the list. He also said Eminem and Nine inch nails didn't deserve to be on that list. He also complained how like a rolling stone was ranked #1 on the best song list and how low Pink Floyd comfortably numb song was. Also complained How Pink Floyd's album dark side of the moon was ranked #43 (I think) and that there were to many Beatles albums in the top 10. Maybe Zappa said it best about rolling stone magazine about calling it stupid (Then again I really don't know I don;t have any thing against this) . So does any body else have any thing against these lists
Ha... this pretty much explains my opinion:
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;...
I normally never agree with any music list from any magazine no matter how reputable they are.
All of these lists are really just opinions, and who's to say that there opinion is any better than any one else's.