Did u like Harry Potter 5?!

Did u like Harry Potter 5?

Cause i really loved it .It rocked! It was really good!

i was extremely disappointed...they ruined my favorite book of the series! they cut out way too much and the parts they did have in seemed to just be just fact after fact with no actual depth or description like in the book. the magical feeling was also lost...i mean the whole movie was shot in some kind of dark, murky lighting, very different from the happy environment. i know this book is darker but does that mean all fantasy and happiness should go? also sirius did not get hit with an AVADA KEDAVRA curse in the book...he just got hit with a spell and fell into the veil....in the movie he was killed by avada kedavra..doesn't that ruin the whole meaning of the veil. the best parts were the fight scenes i think. umbridge was a little of a let down for me too because of the lack of umbridge/other teacher interaction! they completely left out a lot of the interaction between the staff and umbridge especially between minerva and umbridge. they didn't explain anything with kreacher and basically the movie was a disappointment and i have so many more criticisms but ill stop here. being such a huge fan im was kind of angry with myself because i really don't want to see it again. thank you david yates for the horrible directing...the one thing you did seem to get right was luna..thank god!