Are these characters good or evil?!


Question: Are these vengeful horror/action movie characters good, evil, or psychotic?

1. The Punisher
2. Carrie
3. Alessa Gillespie (Silent Hill)

I need to get some opinions for an essay for a college class in film, and I thought I would ask on here.


Answers: Are these vengeful horror/action movie characters good, evil, or psychotic?

1. The Punisher
2. Carrie
3. Alessa Gillespie (Silent Hill)

I need to get some opinions for an essay for a college class in film, and I thought I would ask on here.

The Punisher was an avenger as said before, so I would not say evil...

Carrie was pushed over the edge and she just snapped. I mean pouring blood on someone... Of course they snap! I agree that she could not control her powers. I'm not sure if I would call her "evil". Just strained from being pushed over the edge so she did evil things.

And as for Alessa, she was an innocent child who was burned through no fault of her own! Just like Carrie, she was pushed over the edge and she took out her vengeance! She did TERRIBLE, evil things, but she was only evil because she was made to be so. So yes she became evil because of what the people of Silent Hill did to her.

INTERESTING essay questions. I wish my teachers would give me questions like that! I hope this helps you. Good luck on your essay!

they may have done bad things but only because they were pushed beyond a limit and snapped...otherwise i'd say good

The Punisher is an avenger. He did evil things to get vegeance and his version of justice for killing his family. I would not call him evil.

Carrie did not know how to control her powers. I wouldn't call her evil either, she just got mad and her powers took over without her realizing she was doing it. Her mother was the evil one.

I did not get the concept of the movie Silent Hill so I have no idea if she was evil or not.

ya
what she said

I dont think ANY of them are evil, per se. I think that Carrie was driven to her madness by the way she was treated. The punisher became a vigilante and Alessa Gillespie was burned for being an evil child. I dont know about you but I would have been pretty pissed and had I had those powers, I would have done the same.

i'v only seen the punisher and he is good cause that one guy had all the people he loved killed,, so the punisher had to handle it :) -- ?

I'm sorry I've only seen Carrie but i hope my opinion is of help. I think she was a good, naive person who at the end was filled with hatred and revenge by the bullies at school who made her life a misery and a mother who was psychopath. I think this is one of the cases where society played a big roll in her becoming evil

i would say good for the punisher becuase he is only giving the poeple hwta they derserve since they killed his fmaily

3. it think she is pure evil i mean sure she just wnats a life with a real mom.. lol that also makes her phyco but idk

and im sorry idk what carrie is

I think these characters were essentially good but circumstances drove them to do the "evil" things they did.

The Punisher was none of the above.. he was pissed off. He was putting people in danger in an attempt to punish those that killed his family. He did not think twice about anyone else.. So, he wasn't evil, because they were in fact, bad guys ... but he wasn't psychotic because he was aware of what he was doing.. and he wasn't good because he didn't think about anyone else that might be hurt..


Carrie was good at first.. but was driven to a psychotic episode.. although I think she would have calmed down had people not laughed as much.. She was mentally unstable because of the mother, they just tipped the scale at the prom. Not evil though..

I haven't watched Silent Hill.. so can't really tell.



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories