Who would play the Joker better:Heth Ledger or Jack Nicholson?!


Question: That's kind of unfair to say at this point, as we've seen Nicholson's performance in full, but not yet Ledger's. I see them as each playing a different incarnation of the Joker (he has quite a few due to his longevity). Nicholson's Joker was far more comical, while Ledger's seems to be much darker.

I loved Nicholson's performance, but Ledger seems to be doing a great take on the Joker himself. I would say Nicholson right now, but it remains to be seen how Ledger will do, though he certainly seems promising in the role. If Ledger's performance is anything like his incredible Joker laugh, he might top Nicholson's great performance.


Answers: That's kind of unfair to say at this point, as we've seen Nicholson's performance in full, but not yet Ledger's. I see them as each playing a different incarnation of the Joker (he has quite a few due to his longevity). Nicholson's Joker was far more comical, while Ledger's seems to be much darker.

I loved Nicholson's performance, but Ledger seems to be doing a great take on the Joker himself. I would say Nicholson right now, but it remains to be seen how Ledger will do, though he certainly seems promising in the role. If Ledger's performance is anything like his incredible Joker laugh, he might top Nicholson's great performance.

jack hands down

Guess we will find out this summer.

If you asked me last month I would have said Jack hands down but that trailer looks pretty awesome so I will wait to make judgment.

Jack Nicholson! Of course. :D

Jack
Ever danced with the devil in the pale moon light?

Jack by far, hes scary enough without the makeup and costume now imagine him with it.

jack Nicholson

Ledger would be a pretty sexxy Joker!!! jack is getting old!

Are you serious? The Joker played by Jack is one of the greatest characters ever in cinema history.

ha, jack by a mile. i have seen him act in those roles before-and damn was he brilliant!

Ledger isn't even worthy to tie Jacks shoes for him.

Strange question, obviously Jack Nicholson, at least we've seen his work. I cannot imagine Heath Ledger as the joker, not that he might not be able to pull it off, but I believe he is cut for other parts.

JACK
how could u even wonder
JACK
JACK
JACK

jack nicholson now answer mine my name is reina

Haven't seen Heath's performance as Joker yet, but I wasn't all that thrilled with Jack's over-the-top performance and regurgitation of his Shinning character.

Personally I prefer the Joker from Batman the Animated series. The Emmy award winning one and NOT that stupid Kids WB version.

Are you crazy? You can't even ask such a question. Shame on you.

(Jack Nicholson)

no

Jack Nicholson was a great Joker....

From the previews, Heath Ledger seems he is stealing or trying to be Jack. I just think the won't be as funny and creative with the role like Jack!!

well my first instinct was Jack hands down. but I live heath ledger a lot and if he were to play a funny joker instead of a sinister one I'd give it a try.

Dude, the two aren't comparable, they are two completely different versions of the joker. Jacks is cartoony like the burton movies. Heath's is going to be darker and more psychotic, a little more ''this could actually happen'' realism. I will tell you, being a huge Heath fan, alot of fanboys have ate their words making fun of ''BrokeBack Heath'' after seeing the trailer. Mark my words Ledger will get an Oscar nom for this role, it's going to be unbelievable.

chris farley...

IS this a serious question? Jack definitely.

Jack Nicholson.
:)

Only from the previews I've seen Heath has put a fresh spin on the character and seems to play him well.Its a pity you never asked the question with Cesar Romeo who played the original in the 1960's TV series cause he rocked!



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories