The Song "The Rose" Who Do you think sings it better Janis Joplin? or !


Question: Janis Joplin....
http://www.last.fm/music/Janis+Joplin/+v...
or
Bette Midler

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3udzSmwm6...


Answers: Janis Joplin....
http://www.last.fm/music/Janis+Joplin/+v...
or
Bette Midler

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3udzSmwm6...

Janis Joplin never ever sang this song to begin with.
The first video is lovely and the scenes from ms.Joplin's childhood and what not are lovely but the song was written for the movie "The Rose". It was written by Amanda McBroom and was featured in the movie. I remember seeing it when it came out in '79
Sincerely,I can say that Bette Midler did the superior job of presenting this song simply by default.

bet midler is too uhh, vegasy.....?

Bette Midler....Janis sounds like she ate gravel.

the original...janis joplin !

Bette Midler

I think Westlife added some spice to it :)

Janis Joplin. I don`t think Bette Midler`s voice is very good at all.

JJ :)

they`re both the same,Janis died 1970(?)`71.
Bette Midler sang the rose!!!!

Since I saw the movie The Rose when I was little (and before I heard the original), I am a little partial to the Bette Midler version.

Although it is my opinion that Bette held back a little so her voice could sound as much like Janis' as possible.

They both sound the same. Are you sure Janis Joplin ever sang it?

Bette Midler because she adds so much emotion and "The Rose" was such a GREAT MOVIE, as was "Beaches"-she is just really good!

Bette Midler

Even on the searches I did there seems to be discrepancies both on who wrote or sang this song first. I go with Janis and like the version I heard that was credited to her.



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories